Subpoena for Therapists: What to Do in the First 48 Hours

What to Do in the First 48 Hours After a Subpoena (For Therapists)

What to Do in the First 48 Hours After a Subpoena (For Therapists)

In the first 48 hours after a subpoena for therapists' records arrives, pause. Don't ignore it, and don't hand over anything yet. Call your malpractice insurer first, then an attorney who knows mental health law, and write down every step you take.

By Vanessa Pruitt, MS, LIMHP, CPC, RPT™ · Updated November 16, 2026

Seeing a subpoena land on your desk can make your stomach drop, especially in a custody case where you care about the child and the family. The good news is that the first two days don't require you to have every answer. They require a calm, short plan. Here is the plan I use and teach for any subpoena for therapists.

What is the first thing I should do when I receive a subpoena?

Pause. Don't ignore it, because ignoring a subpoena can lead to legal penalties. And don't assume it means you must disclose everything it asks for.

It also helps to know what you're holding. A subpoena is a formal request, usually from an attorney, to appear or produce records. A court order is a direction from a judge. That difference shapes what you do next, so note which one you have, the date you received it, and who sent it.

Who should I call first, and in what order?

Call your malpractice insurer first, then an attorney who knows mental health law in your state. Many insurers have a risk-management line for exactly this situation.

Then share the subpoena, and any related orders, with the attorney. Ask them to walk you through your options, including whether it makes sense to negotiate the scope of what's requested or ask the court to limit it. If the subpoena concerns an adult client, your attorney can also advise on how and when to let the client know.

How do I check what my clients consented to?

Pull your informed consent and release forms before you respond to anyone. They tell you what you promised about confidentiality and what clients already agreed to.

Look for three things: what you explained about the limits of confidentiality and possible court involvement, who signed (in custody cases, parents may disagree about who has the authority), and whether any court orders are already on file. Review the record as it stands. Don't edit or add to it.

What if the subpoena asks for a child's records?

Slow down even more. Children's treatment information needs extra care, and parents in conflict can complicate who has the authority to release it.

Your attorney can explain the process in your state. Depending on the situation, options can include asking the court to limit what's released or involving a guardian ad litem or other advocate for the child. Be ready to explain the clinical risks and benefits of releasing or withholding information, including what it could mean for the child's trust in therapy.

What if I'm asked to testify?

Don't agree on the spot. Get guidance first, then decide how to respond.

If you do testify, stay in your role as the treating therapist. That means speaking to what you observed and did: diagnosis, behavior and changes in treatment, the treatment plan, and progress. It does not mean offering opinions on custody, parenting capacity, or who should make decisions for a child. Those questions belong to the court and to forensic evaluators, not to the therapist the child trusts.

What should I write down?

Keep a simple log from the first hour. Record the date and time you received the subpoena, who contacted you, what was requested, who you called and when, and what advice you were given.

A clear, contemporaneous log shows you acted carefully, and it saves you from reconstructing events from memory weeks later.

Free: First-48-Hours Checklist (one page, PDF).

All of the steps above on a single page you can keep where you'll find it fast. Get the free checklist

If you work with court-involved families regularly, the Court-Involved Family Intake Bundle™ gives you editable Word files for the paperwork that makes these situations easier to handle: $97, with a single-practice license.

Want a second set of eyes on your own situation or your forms? You can book a consultation.

Frequently asked questions about a subpoena for therapists

Is a subpoena the same as a court order?
No. A subpoena is a formal request, usually from an attorney, to appear or produce records. A court order comes from a judge. Which one you have affects how you respond, so check before you do anything else.

Do I have to release records as soon as I get a subpoena?
Not automatically. Don't ignore it, but don't assume it requires you to disclose everything. Talk with your malpractice insurer and an attorney about what you can and should release.

Should I tell my client about the subpoena?
Often yes, especially for adult clients, but your attorney can guide the timing and how to do it. Document your efforts to notify them.

Can I give an opinion on custody if I'm asked in court?
In general, a treating therapist should stay within the treatment role and decline opinions on custody or parenting capacity. Confirm how this applies to you with your attorney before you testify.

This post is general information for clinicians and is not legal advice. Talk to your malpractice insurer or an attorney about your specific situation.

Free for therapists: Subpoenaed in a Custody Case? The First-48-Hours Checklist

A 3-page PDF covering what to do before you respond, what to check in your consent paperwork, and who to call.

Educational only, not legal advice. Consult an attorney about your situation. — Vanessa Pruitt, MS, LIMHP, CPC, RPT™

You Might Also Like